The NFL's shallow wave

A plain football rests on the grass at a yard line in a packed stadium at sunset. A glowing line of small, gentle waves runs across the image beneath the title The NFL's Shallow Wave.

On the front page of this site I describe what I'm reaching for as a shallow wave -- small swings, with the whole line riding high. People sometimes hear that as a dream. The NFL has been running a version of it for decades.

Rivals who share the rules

The league is thirty-two separate businesses. Their owners compete hard -- for players, for coaches, for fans. They aren't friends, and in 2010 the Supreme Court said as much in American Needle v. NFL, ruling that the teams are separate competitors, not one company.

But they agreed on a set of rules that keep any of them from running away with it.

The draft. In 1935, Bert Bell proposed that the team with the worst record should pick first from the next class of college players, and everyone else in reverse order of the standings. The first draft was held in February 1936. Bell owned the Philadelphia Eagles, and the Eagles had the worst record in the league, so they got the first pick. I like that he didn't pretend to be selfless. He needed the rule, and so did the league -- bidding wars for players were draining the weaker teams.

Television. In 1961 Congress passed the Sports Broadcasting Act, which let the league sell its TV rights as one package. The money is split evenly. A team in a small city gets the same national TV share as a team in the biggest market in the country, and the big-market teams agreed to it, even though they could have done better alone.

The salary cap. Since 1994, each team can spend only so much on players. No owner, however rich, can buy every good one.

Why the strong agreed to it

The owners worked out something that a lot of industries never do. If the gap between the top and the bottom gets too wide, the whole thing dies. Nobody watches a game when they already know who wins. So the strong teams accepted limits on how strong they could get, and every spring the weakest team gets first pick.

None of it depends on anyone's generosity. Nobody has to feel charitable in March for the worst team to get the first pick in April. The release is in the rules, on the calendar. It's the same thing I wrote about in The release came first -- the structure does the work, so the good intentions don't have to.

Who the wave doesn't reach

There's a limit, though. The NFL keeps the wave shallow between the owners. It does much less for the people outside the room.

If you love a team, you can't take it with you to another league -- there isn't one. Cities often help pay for stadiums, partly because a team can threaten to move. The commissioner who disciplines the owners is hired by the owners. Run the NFL through the five tests and it struggles on the first and the fourth: leaving is hard, and accountability isn't independent.

So the league proves the shallow wave can be built, by rivals, out of self-interest, and that it lasts. It also shows that a structure built by the people inside the room tends to protect the people inside the room.

The question I'm left with

The owners shared the rules because they all needed the league to survive. Would they ever give the same deal to the fans who pay for it? I don't know. I don't see what would make them, unless the fans had somewhere else to go.

What I'm sure of is that it can be built. Thirty-two rivals have been doing it since 1936.

-- Richard Whitney. Write to me if this lands with you, or if you think I've got it wrong. More posts.

Comments

No comments yet.

Add a comment

Claude, an AI model, checks each comment against five rules in a few seconds. Disagreeing with me is never against them. Anything it isn't sure about waits for me. If yours isn't published, this page says so and why, and if you leave an email, you'll hear directly and can ask me to look at it myself. The email is never shown and never used for anything else.